Things are not loooking so rosy elsewhere however. People may be aware that Brian Adair has had his organic business up for sale for a while. I know there have been interested parties, but so far nothing has materialised. He was the first certified organic producer in the Island and has a well established business with a strong customer base. If thats not viable or attractive as a business , then some serious questions need to be asked politically of ministers about what they do think is valuable and worthwhile in the Island.
In reality the answers will be made obvious today in the States with the MTFP debate. It comes down to one thing economic growth - the magic fairy dust that, like entropy in thermodynamics and dark matter in cosmology, has to be conjoured up conceptually to make the number work according to the the theory.
Unsurprisingly I have been asked by a number of people if I am going to take on Brian's business. I suppose it is an obvious question as I do go on so much about organic food, have some experience as a smalholder and have run a few successful businesses in the past. I have not entertained the possibility previously. There are several reasons.
What I do in my own field is not a commercial operation - I don't intend it to be. It is informal research based on my observations of that might constitute a bioethical food production system. It is deliberately small scale and in the last few years devoid of all mechanisation. There's the first problem - scale. Brian's operation would need at least 2 people to work as a market garden/horticultural concern, based on Eliot Coleman's maximum 2.5 acres per person observation. Plus of course I'd still have my fields to manage and maintain. That means going back to a walk behind tractor at least, and that takes me away from the direction I have been experimenting on.
Another reason I havent entertained it was commitment. I am at an age where I have probably energy and time for one , perhaps just two big projects left in my life. Big projects I think of as those that require 'all in' effort - typically starting a new business is like that - certainly those I have done before have been. In the current state of organic production locally it certainly would have to be an all consuming commitment. If I were to do that it would have to be the right project. There is a sort of opportunity costs here - other projects would have to be ditched or forgone.
All that (and more) before even looking at the commercial figures and viability. It is a fact that in Jersye access to the land is controlled. Even if you own fields you are not allowed to work them unless you have permission! There are financial requirements of marginal profit be a bona fide farmer (£40,000 per year) and to occupy good agricultural land, or even more than a few vergees of less favoured land you have to qualify financially (interestingly they appear to have dropped the main income from farming obligation that used to exist, I wonder why ;) ) See Land Control
There is a facebook group looking at the possibilities for saving the farm . See https://www.facebook.com/groups/1577795972527334/ The groups s interested in a Community Supported Agriculture model. It has worked elsewhere. There's a useful UK site on how that might work at Community Supported Agriculture. The Soil Association also has promoted CSA for organic production. It is certainly a better bet than hoping the States of Jersey will support organic agriculture in the Island!
I posted on that group some thoughts about how this might go forward. I've reproduced them below.
I
know people are interested in CSA, but there may be another way to do
this. If you have seen any of my rantings over the last 2 years you
will know we have been losing certified organic land and growers for
some time. Warnings fell on deaf ears politically. We have long had a
problem in Jersey that farming and horticulture is viewed as a purely
commercial activity. It can be done that way of course- that's how you
get the agri chemical industry. But it needn't be. 2,500
years ago Hippocrates said (in greek of course!) Let food be thy
medicine and medicine be thy food. I've posted a link below to a scheme
in the USA taking that literally.
It isn't just immediate human health we need to consider either. There
is the health of the soil and less well known to many is its ability to
sequester carbon from the atmosphere. Possibly the last great hope for
avoiding significant climate change. And there is the diversity and
abundance and health of the eco system and biology around agriculture
and horticulture - the water quality, wildlife and the psychological
benefits of access to deep nature.
Put that lot together and it suggests to me a different approach , a different mind set is required. Not a commercial venture but a social one. Not a financial imperative, but a health one. If you think of it as a business the particiapnts expect a return. If you think of it as a charity , you get a different answer. Its not incompatible with CSA you can have supporting subscribers and charities can and do have volunteer workers and paid professionals.
The question is whether you are in it just for what you can get out of it, or for what good can come out of it.
In Jersey we have low-income people with diabetes and high blood pressure. So what about this bleedin' obvious idea from the USA. Load fresh fruits and vegetables into a refrigerator truck and drive it to a health clinic. To improve the diet have a doctor write a “prescription” for food . Even better if it were local wholesome organic produce.
Put that lot together and it suggests to me a different approach , a different mind set is required. Not a commercial venture but a social one. Not a financial imperative, but a health one. If you think of it as a business the particiapnts expect a return. If you think of it as a charity , you get a different answer. Its not incompatible with CSA you can have supporting subscribers and charities can and do have volunteer workers and paid professionals.
The question is whether you are in it just for what you can get out of it, or for what good can come out of it.
In Jersey we have low-income people with diabetes and high blood pressure. So what about this bleedin' obvious idea from the USA. Load fresh fruits and vegetables into a refrigerator truck and drive it to a health clinic. To improve the diet have a doctor write a “prescription” for food . Even better if it were local wholesome organic produce.
